(Road Trip Wednesday question)
This one's easy.
Paula would want something expensive. Jewelry would be nice, or perhaps a gift card to some expensive clothing store*. (Emphasis on the "gift card" part. People always get her size wrong.)
Olivia would prefer something home-made. Gifts always mean more when a loved one puts their time, attention, and creativity into them. But if that's not possible, she would be happy with an iTunes or Barnes and Noble gift card.
*I still need to come up with a fictional designer's name, since I hate brand name dropping.